When you have light skin and light eyelashes you may find that ultra black mascara looks a little funky on your eyes. If you are looking for a softer and more natural look adopting a brown mascara can be the best way to achieve this. If you have green or blue eyes the brown hues often bring out the natural color of your eyes and make them stand out more than any other feature.
Mascara is one of the accessories and addons most women start experimenting with as girls. Depending on the brand and type it can lengthen, bolden, and even curl. Some formulas are meant to last all days and others are meant to be worn for a short amount of time and be soothing. Which kind can be best for you?
We know it’s confusing and there are so many brands to choose from, but we have made it easy for you. Read on to find the best brown mascara to buy for your future makeup looks.
- The 15 Top Choices For Brown Mascara:
- 1. Blinc Brown Mascara
- 2. Benefit They’re Real Beyond Mascara
- 3. Brown Mascara by Endlessly Beautiful
- 4. Dr. Hauschka Volume Mascara
- 5. Kiss Me Heroine Make Long & Curl Mascara Brown
- 6. Ecco Bella FlowerColor Mascara
- 7. Pacifica Beauty Stellar Gaze Length & Strength Mascara Stardust
- 8. Clinique Lash Power Mascara
- 9. Honeybee Gardens Truly Natural Mascara
- 10. Christian Dior Diorshow Lash Extension Effect
- 11. Maybelline Volum’ Express Mascara
- 12. NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Tinted Brow Mascara
- 13. Cover Girl Lash Blast Volume Mascara
- 14. Lancome Definicils Mascara
- 15. W3LL PEOPLE
The 15 Top Choices For Brown Mascara:
1. Blinc Brown Mascara
We love this mascara because it is truly fade-proof. If you are like us, you work long days and need something that is long-lasting but will help your natural beauty pop. This will add subtle length to your lashes that last while you go from work to the gym and out to a casual dinner with friends. The best part is you can easily wipe it off with makeup remover.
This is an incredibly decent waterproof brown mascara that you should try to look for something easy to use. If you have sensitive eyes, this formula is meant to be gentle. It won’t cause damage or irritation around your eyes but will sit all day softly without leaving streaks.
2. Benefit They’re Real Beyond Mascara
The tube is a silvery pink, and the packaging is beautiful. However, Benefit always goes beyond fantastic packaging. They top it off with an incredible formula that works wonders. This brown mascara not only lengthens but also curls and strengthens eyelashes. The brush attached to the end of the wand is meant to help separate eyelashes, which will also help avoid unwanted clumps.
Related: Best Heated Eyelash Curlers
There are staggered bristles that help get a full coat of the mascara onto your eyes. The staggering helps cover the roots and the tips all in one swipe. For extra coverage, you can use two swipes. The formula is meant to be glossy and give your lashes a silky brown appearance.
3. Brown Mascara by Endlessly Beautiful
This Mascara can help give your lashes a fuller and more robust look. It is one of the best light brown mascaras you can find and will help you achieve a soft look to your beautiful eyes.
This formula is meant to be water-resistant, so it will last all day long. It is a vegan formula perfect for gifts for people with sensitive eyes. It will glide on smoothly and give your lashes a full and long look. Everyone will wonder what you use!
Related: Best Eyeliners for Sensitive Eyes
4. Dr. Hauschka Volume Mascara
Alright, admittedly, every light brown mascara on this list is excellent, but this may be the best one of all. Dr. Hauschka has got to be one of the best skincare lines you will ever find, but they also make mascara! This formula will help create thicker lashes that add volume to your eyes, and the best part about this is that it will not harm your eyes.
This formula will not irritate your lashes or eyes; it will be gentle thanks to the natural ingredients. This company refuses to test on animals, and every ingredient is sourced naturally and manufactured with fair trade in mind.
5. Kiss Me Heroine Make Long & Curl Mascara Brown
This light brown mascara works wonders for a natural look. Many users love using it on the bottom lashes because it helps lengthen slightly without looking overdone. It is gentle and is excellent for many types of eyelashes. If you have thin lashes, this will work wonders for you.
The best way to get this product off is with makeup remover; the formula sticks well. It will last all day long and will need extra scrubbing to get off. The wand makes it easy to coat your lashes quickly if you are in a rush, and the packaging is super cute.
6. Ecco Bella FlowerColor Mascara
The best thing about this mascara is there are literally six ingredients in it. All of these are clearly labeled, and you know exactly what you’re putting on your lashes, which makes this brand super attractive for many consumers. It is not waterproof but will last all day if you take proper care throughout the day.
This formula is meant to glide on smoothly without any clumps or caking, so it will not look overly done up, and it will provide a very natural look. This is one of the best if you want to make individual lashes longer and more luxurious looking without adding extra chemicals.
7. Pacifica Beauty Stellar Gaze Length & Strength Mascara Stardust
This is a mineral mascara meant for long-lasting results. Pacifica is known for some of the most outstanding natural beauty in our society, and their light brown mascara is one of the best, so of course, it has to be added to our list. Some of the ingredients you will find here are coconut water and vitamin B, all great for nourishing lashes.
It is made free of parabens, silicone, and phthalates; this brand is cruelty-free and vegan. You will get long, beautiful, and vegan lashes using the Stellar Gaze mascara. This can be one of the best mascara to invest in if you are into natural beauty.
8. Clinique Lash Power Mascara
Now, when you think of brown mascara, you may be thinking of something lighter good for green and blue eyes. Generally, this is true. However, Clinique has made a dark chocolate brown mascara good for all eye colors. It will stay all day without budging, making it great for almost everyone. It is fragrance-free and will not irritate your eyes. You can wash it off with makeup remover or soap and water.
It is a natural-looking mascara, so it will not add an outrageous amount of volume. If you are looking for something to put on under your false eyelashes, this can be one of the best mascaras to choose.
9. Honeybee Gardens Truly Natural Mascara
This is a silky formula meant to help define lashes and last long. When Honeybee created this formula, they wanted to prove their natural mascara could be as good, if not better, than all of the other mascara made with chemicals. There is no clumping in this formula, no caking. It provides all-day color and will provide conditioning to each lash that has been coated thoroughly.
This formula is botanically enriched and also water-resistant, helping you achieve a fade proof look though not waterproof. Once you wash your face, this mascara will come off easily. This mascara is made in the United States with all organic ingredients.
10. Christian Dior Diorshow Lash Extension Effect
The bristles on this brush are magnificent and help create the longest lashes ever. This formula is supposed to create the look of lash extensions that come off every night quickly. There is an airlock on the tube itself, which will help prevent your formula from drying out; it also reduces any clumps that may end up on your wand.
You can swipe it on easily, each eye in under a minute. Each lash will be fully coated and last all day. It is excellent for work makeup but is very natural, and you may find it too natural if you are headed to the club or party.
11. Maybelline Volum’ Express Mascara
This is one of the most convenient light brown mascaras you will find in your local convenience store. Maybelline is a massive brand in the beauty world because they create well-formulated products at a budget-friendly price, and they work for almost everyone. This brush is meant to be ultra-plumping and lengthen every single lash.
This is great for both upper and lower lashes helping you achieve plump natural lashes. The brush they have created helps deliver dramatic volume without looking overly barbie-esque. The formula has collagen in it, which helps nourish, heal and protect your lashes, allowing them to grow even while you wear this mascara.
The best thing about this mascara is that it won’t cause any irritation even if you wear contact lenses. You can also wash this all off at the end of your busy day.
12. NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Tinted Brow Mascara
Have you ever heard of mascara for your brows? Well, it’s here! This is almost precisely what you would imagine a brow mascara to look like. It helps hold the shape of your brows in place while providing color over your entire look.
This comes in a light brown or blonde shade, perfect for anyone with light hair and a fair complexion. The best thing about this brand is that you can find this product in a few different colors. This will keep your arches smooth and on fleek. It will stay soft all day without turning hard or clumpy.
You can fill them in, shape them, and set them, and it will last until you wash it off. NYX produces cruelty-free cosmetics, meaning they do not test on any animals ever.
13. Cover Girl Lash Blast Volume Mascara
This mascara is said to create ten times more volume than any other mascara, and Cover Girl knows their formula. On top of that, this mascara comes in four different colors so you can find the perfect shade for your eyes.
There will be no clumps. It will glide over your lashes effortlessly in under a minute. After a long day, you will find that the formula does not flake away or become dry. Your lashes will stay moisturized and nourished all day long.
There will be no smudging throughout the day, and it will last until you take it off. It will provide instant full lashes. This brand is also cruelty-free, making it one of the most appealing drug store brands you can find.
14. Lancome Definicils Mascara
This is a deep brown mascara perfect for most eye colors. The formula is not runny but will also not clump around your eyelashes. It should glide on with no difficulties. You can wash this formula off with soap and water. They want to ensure that your lashes look natural but outstanding and eye-catching.
In this formula, you will find vitamin B5 and panthenol, which is great for nourishing your lashes. It will coat your lashes from root to tip, making them stand out. It comes with a fine comb brush that will help separate your lashes that have become tangly.
15. W3LL PEOPLE
Last but not least W3LL PEOPLE Natural Expressionist Volumizing Mascara, a non-toxic formula that will enhance your lashes. It is a clean formula that is a light brown mascara and good for anyone with fair skin and light eyes.
It is plant-based and cruelty-free. It helps create glamorous lashes after just a few swipes but also helps nourish and protect your lashes. It has an hourglass-shaped wand that is perfect for defining and lengthening your natural lashes.
It has a naturally eye-popping effect that is hard to beat. There are no artificial chemicals, so if you have sensitive eyes, we would recommend trying this mascara out!
There are many amazing choices. You can look at all of them and give your eyes a soft brown natural look. If you are looking for one with a natural and reputable line, we recommend using Dr. Hauschka’s mascara. If you want something that you can find at your local store, you should try out Maybelline Volum’ Express mascara.
No matter what you choose, you will create stunning lashes with these top choices. If you have sensitive eyes, you should be sure to read about the brand and the ingredients they use; if you think you may be allergic, take it off immediately.
Joan S. Wilson is a lifelong makeup and skincare enthusiast. She used to work as a makeup artist for 5 years. Joan is always curious and wants to learn more when it comes to makeup and skincare. She tries her best to make other people’s skin health better. This is why Joan is so passionate about writing articles on beauty topics. She always looks for products that are high-quality, dermatologist-tested, and does that it says on the label. In every article, she shares her knowledge to make your life healthier and happier!