One of the hottest trends is a nice sleek cat-eye look. It can help make or break a romantic look and be one of the best addition to your work look. Eyeliner can help enhance your eyes, make them look smaller, larger, or even wider. However, if you have sensitive eyes, this could be a massive problem for you because many formulas hinder your delicate eyelids.
If you have delicate skin around your eyes, do not fear! We have come up with a list of the best eyeliner for sensitive eyes. This list is for you; keep reading to find some of the best products.
- Our Top 15 Recommended Eyeliners for Sensitive Eyes:
- 1. Stila Liquid Eyeliner
- 2. Blinc Semi-Permanent Eyeliner
- 3. Bobbi Brown Gel Eyeliner
- 4. Ecco Bella Natural Eyeliner
- 5. INIKA Organic Pencil
- 6. Clinique Quickliner
- 7. Maybelline Eyestudio Eyeliner
- 8. Julep Eyeliner
- 9. Fifth’s and Skin Better’n Ur Eyes Eyeliner
- 10. Physicians Formula Eye Booster
- 11. BaeBlu Natural Hypoallergenic Eyeliner
- 12. Burts Bees Nourishing Eyeliner
- 13. Sephora Collection
- 14. Almay Eyeliner
- 15. NYX Epic Eyeliner
Our Top 15 Recommended Eyeliners for Sensitive Eyes:
1. Stila Liquid Eyeliner
This pen is easy to control because of the long slender pen-like body. It gives you a nice handle to grasp. The tip is soft enough to quickly move around while being stiff enough to provide you with a decent amount of liquid on your eyelids. It offers a precise application that other liquid eyeliners may not be able to offer you. This liquid eyeliner is meant to make your eyes look bigger and broader, making it perfect for a photoshoot or selfie-game.
You will want to shake this before using it, and only use the very tip of the pen for a clean, sleek, and thin line on your lashes. Stila liquid eyeliner is a waterproof formula that will stay all day and not smudge with your other makeup. Typically, waterproof formulas can be harsh on your face.
Still, this one can be taken off very quickly with an oil-based makeup remover that will not harm your skin or eyes. This product will last all day long and take you from day to night without reapplying 100 times.
2. Blinc Semi-Permanent Eyeliner
This is a sleek looking bottle coming in a silver tube; it looks beautiful and provides a great liner. The best feature of this product is that it comes in four different shades. This line offers black, blue, grey, and purple to choose from. Each shade is intensely pigmented, which will allow your eyes to pop while still feeling good all day long.
It will not make your eyes feel overly dry, it will not sit heavy on your lids, and it will quickly come off at the end of the day. It is water-resistant and will stay on even if you work out; the best way to get it off your face will be to use an oil-based makeup remover. However, that is not necessary. If you would rather use warm water, that is all that is truly required!
Use tons of warm water and some slight pressure to get this liquid eyeliner off your eyes. It will not fade throughout the day and will provide a smudge-free look. This should be applied to clean and dry skin. Otherwise, it will not stick properly. To get the complete look, you should use your favorite mascara meant for sensitive skin.
3. Bobbi Brown Gel Eyeliner
A gel liner coming in the form of a small pot with a hard liquid in it and cannot be beaten. You will need to buy a small eyeliner brush to apply this one correctly. The best thing about this eyeliner is that you can choose any type of brush you want to create the thickness of the line you desire.
It is a long-wear gel eyeliner formula meaning that it will last all day long, creating the best look from morning to night. You will not need to reapply throughout the day; it will merely last from the minute you put it on your eyelids. It is a soft gel that will glide on your eyelids and not hurt them or cause damage.
Our favorite way to apply this liquid gel is with a smudge brush to help create the perfect line across your lashes. It is a tiny container but is excellent for someone who uses eyeliner for special occasions only. This is such a good eyeliner and can be removed so easily it will not irritate your eyes at all.
4. Ecco Bella Natural Eyeliner
We love this eyeliner because it is natural and comes in a pencil’s shape. It is easy to control, and almost a charcoal-like material. However, it will not damage your eyelids. This is a great eyeliner for a nice smudge look or dark circles, but not if you want to do a sleek cat-eye look.
The best feature is that it is 100% vegan and totally a plant-based eyeliner. This makes it the best hypoallergenic eyeliner you can find on the market. Ecco Bella natural eyeliner is made of plant and vegetable oils that allow it to glide on easily and create the perfect look quickly and conveniently.
It is formulated to be able to last all day without looking smudgy or fading. Ecco Bella is one of our favorite brands because they focus on ethical and clean beauty. You can find them very easily. This is, without a doubt, the best eyeliner for sensitive eyes. It is also incredibly easy to remove; simply wash your face, and it will slide right off with the rest of the day’s impurities.
5. INIKA Organic Pencil
This is a budget-friendly sweet eyeliner and will help totally transform your eyes. INIKA carries 8 different shades, all rich in pigment, and some of the best eyeliner for sensitive eyelids. We love this pencil eyeliner because it is another 100% vegan formula, totally cruelty-free, and all the ingredients are organic.
This brand aims to find the purest locations in the world to gather and obtain their ingredients for each formula. INIKA has created a completely non-toxic formula that is also the best hypoallergenic eyeliner on the market. You can glide this formula right on your eyelids; it has a nice creamy texture.
The texture in this product also makes it very easy to blend with your eyeshadows and last all day long. It has a rich consistency making it easy on your delicate eyelids. Every shade of this product is a very intense natural color used for a spikey cat-eye look or a blended out smokey eye appearance. No matter what look you’re going for, rest assured INIKA Organic Pencil has got you covered.
6. Clinique Quickliner
This is such a fun liner coming from a very well-known brand. Clinique has made some of the best makeup products you could find on the market. They have been in business for 52 years and are constantly keeping up with the beauty trends to see them for much longer.
This specific shade is in moss green and will look amazing with hazel colored eyes. It is dark enough you can blend it in with other colors, or you can use this on its own to make your beautiful eyes pop. The color is rich in pigment and will last all day, which is crucial for us busy women.
It glides on easily, and you can quickly fix any mistakes even though it is sturdy enough to stay on your lids throughout the day. Though this product is no longer in the department stores, you can easily find it online for sale, and at a great price.
7. Maybelline Eyestudio Eyeliner
We love this one because it is so convenient to find. If you don’t feel like ordering online, it is truly no problem because you can find it in most pharmacies near you. This is a no-smudge formula that is soft and gently making it the best eyeliner for sensitive eyes.
There are no harsh chemicals used in this product, each added in to give you a gentle swipe and a lasting look. The tip on this pen-like eyeliner will help you achieve the best cat-eye look that no other pencil could provide you. This unique tip also gets thicker at the base, so if you hold it just the right way, it can help you achieve the proper line thickness.
The best way to remove your new eyeliner is by using micellar water. You can spray it or dab it on your face and remove everything with a cotton ball or washcloth at the end of the day. You can wear this for up to 12 hours with no irritation or smudges. This can be used for a day look or a night look; with this eyeliner pen, you do not have to limit yourself.
8. Julep Eyeliner
We love this brand because not only does it provide 12 amazing pigmented shades. It also offers a unique formula making it one of the best hypoallergenic eyeliners. It glides on smoothly without causing skin damage. It will not irritate your eyes because there are no super harsh chemicals in this eyeliner.
Our favorite shade is in the color fig and looks impressive on hazel, green or brown eyes. If you have blue eyes, we recommend the silver shimmer shade that will surely make your eyes look a bit icy. The tip will almost remind you of a soft color pencil but can slide over your eyelids without the pointy tip.
It is a waterproof formula that will last for hours with no need for touch-ups or adjustments throughout your busy workday. This will help you go from busy work to a romantic date in a jiffy. It is a creamy formula that will work skillfully on your skin. You will need to give it thirty seconds per lash to set appropriately. After that, it can last up to ten hours!
9. Fifth’s and Skin Better’n Ur Eyes Eyeliner
It is quite the name for a pencil, but the bold name is fitting. It is a paraben-free formula, 100% cruelty-free, and a vegetarian option for all our beautiful lovelies out there who are concerned. This is a creamy textured eyeliner that is meant to be the best hypoallergenic eyeliners.
This brand has made something extraordinary for sensitive eyes and made it a staple in a young ladies’ makeup routine. It provides a rich and dark color that can be used to enhance each lash line and stay on an insane amount of time with no need for a touchup. This brand offers two shades of eyeliner, one in black and one in dark brown.
For all the ladies with deep and dark eyes, a phenomenal way to draw attention is to use the black shade, for all the girls with lighter eyes the dark brown will do you so much justice. You should always experiment with different colors to find one that matches your vibe. The best thing about this product is that it is budget-friendly, you can buy both and try them out! There is a decent amount of wax and nice seed oil in this product.
10. Physicians Formula Eye Booster
This is a serious double whammy. On top of being an eyeliner, it is also a soothing fragrance-free serum that will help protect your eyes. This is a Japanese makeup formula that is to die for. It is totally smudge-resistant, meaning it will last all day with no problems, but it will also be super easy to take off if you need to.
This will stay while you work, go to the gym, and chase your kiddos around all day without looking down. The brush tip is a very fine point that allows you to get a super sleek look, or you can blend it out to get a soft look for a romantic date night.
This is a no scent formula, so it will not sting or burn your eyes or harm your sense of smell. It also makes it one of the best hypoallergenic eyeliner you can find on the list. If you wear contacts every day, this could be the best eyeliner for you!
11. BaeBlu Natural Hypoallergenic Eyeliner
Okay, this eyeliner is amazing, and this brand carries ten different shades. This has a mixture of wax and a beautiful blend of oils that make it smooth and easy to glide over sensitive eyelids.
It is a fragrance-free formula making it one of the safest eyeliners to glide on your skin. Nothing can compare to this formula; it is meant to protect and look glamorous all at the same time. There are no chemicals, but the natural formula does not hinder the color.
There is an insane amount of pigment in each eyeliner stick. It will last all day without looking tired or coming off by the end of the day. This is made with certified organic ingredients, which can be highly crucial for some folks!
12. Burts Bees Nourishing Eyeliner
Just like the name states, this eyeliner nourishes your eyelids. It is not a rough and grimy material like others and will leave your lids feeling hydrated and light. You will make your eyes pop and stand out without having anything too heavy to keep your eyes closed.
Each ingredient is responsibly sourced and doesn’t harm the environment when collecting and making this product. There is no synthetic fragrance and absolutely no parabens in it.
You can buy this product in three different shades; no matter what look you’re going for; you will be able to find the best color for your eyes. This eyeliner does contain mango oil, so that is something you will have to be very careful of if you have an allergy.
13. Sephora Collection
A retractable eyeliner that is hard to beat. This eyeliner is waterproof and matte black, making it easy to wear all day long at work, the gym, or on a date.
The matte black allows you to have a sexy and sleek look without it being over the top. The shade also will enable you to blend with your shadow easily. You can add some glitter on top of this eyeliner if you feel a bit extra and give it some glow.
The best part about this eyeliner is that you can use an extra tip to smudge the liner at the bottom. If it is on your bottom lash line, you can use the tip to blend it out and give yourself a dark and smoky look.
14. Almay Eyeliner
Coming in the color of black pearl, this eyeliner will fit most eye colors. It is so versatile and easy to wear that it has made it on our list. This band carries seven different shades of eyeliner, all with the same ingredients but different colors. Four of these colors are shades of brown, making it perfect for every eye color.
This brand really dedicates their shades to giving you the perfect everyday look. If you have sensitive eyes, this brand will be perfect for you; nothing about their eyeliner is heavy. However, it is soft, durable, and will never smudge. This is a fantastic option for a natural look.
15. NYX Epic Eyeliner
NYX is a brand known for its professional-looking makeup. This eyeliner did not let the brand down. It is a lovely shade of black that is entirely waterproof. You could go to a pool part and still carry the sleek look this liner provides.
There is a very pointed tip that allows you to get the pointiest cat-eye look ever. There are four shades to choose from, black, brown, sapphire, and white.
No matter what look you’re going for, you can find something that will match your vibe and, of course, your outfit. It is a high-quality formula that many celebrities wear and will make you look like a model. It’s affordable and very trendy.
All of these are meant to give you the best looks ever. Nothing can compare to some of these insanely well-made eyeliners. If you want to take your look to the next level, try purchasing Blinc Semi-Permanent eyeliner. It will help you create a distinctive look that no one else has but can also be used for a softer natural look. All of these are meant to be the best eyeliner for sensitive eyes. You can’t go wrong with this ultimate list.
Joan S. Wilson is a lifelong makeup and skincare enthusiast. She used to work as a makeup artist for 5 years. Joan is always curious and wants to learn more when it comes to makeup and skincare. She tries her best to make other people’s skin health better. This is why Joan is so passionate about writing articles on beauty topics. She always looks for products that are high-quality, dermatologist-tested, and does that it says on the label. In every article, she shares her knowledge to make your life healthier and happier!